UTL and School Committee must sit down face to face..is it time to look at Fees?


The teachers union wants a raise, so does the support staff. The Lowell School Committee Must have some concessions or changes they want to make.

The only way anything will get done is to meet face to face to talk. BOTH sides claims the other has stalled or cancelled meetings. ENOUGH!

Stop playing the blame game and meet July 21st face to face and get this deal don.

IF has reported in today’s Sun the city has offered a 2.5% increase over two years that is a fair offer. What we don’t know is what concessions the Committee is asking for.

IF today’s Sun report of the union wanting a 12% raise over three years, that seems excess.

According to a Sun story from May of this year, approx. employee salaries for the fiscal year 2015/2016 school year,includes $73.7 million for teachers, $11.4 for administrators and $8.85 for paraprofessionals out of an $154,368,116 over all budget. (Over 60% of the entire budget is Salaries)

Most of us who work for a living think we deserve a raise. What we do is valuable to the company. In the case of teachers and support staff there is no doubt that they serves a vital role in the community.

The Union made concessions a few years ago and joined the GIC for health insurance. We are told by the City Manager that both 2015 and the forecast for 2016 show’s a decrease in cost for health insurance when most of us are not only seeing a rise in cost, like the teacher’s and support staff we are seeing a rise in deductibles and out-of-pocket expenses.

Did that savings reach the rank and file? Has anyone asked?

So how do we find more revenue to support giving the teachers and support staff even a .5% raise which would be approx. $600,000?

Have we reached a point that maybe Lowell has to take a step back and look at instituting fees for Clubs, Music/Theater , Athletics and busing? How many of the 14,000 students enrolled in the public school system actually take part in these program and what is the overall cost?

Take a look at most of the surrounding communities in the Merrimack Valley, many have fee’s. If the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, than shouldn’t we look at any and all ways to generate monies to help offset the operations of these specialized programs?

Kids pay fees for local baseball, Pop Warner Football, private swim, wrestling and baseball clubs. Even your neighborhood churches charge a fee for CCD classes. If we need to increase taxes to pay for salary increases, shouldn’t we first look at what is vital and what can be at least partly paid for by the people using the service to subsidize it?

Haverhill Mass charges $100 per sport with a $600 family Max and if a student receives free lunch the fee is waived if they receive a reduced lunch the fee is halved.

Without even looking at the cost of busing (future Post) here is what some of the neighboring communities charge in fees for sports and clubs.

Tewksbury- $150 Fee NO Cap
Dracut – $150 per sport , $900 Cap
Billerica – $150 Fam Max at $600

Tyngsboro has a layered system – Middle School: 1st Sport $200 / 2nd Sport $175 / 3rd Sport $150
High School: 1st Sport $300 / 2nd Sport $200 / 3rd Sport $100

Boston nor Brockton or Worcester charge any fee’s at the moment.

Interestingly Newton which is a pretty wealthy community has a very structured Fee Schedule

Screen Shot 2015-06-29 at 2.05.58 PM

Did this school Committee get together before contract talks began and form a united front and agree on what they wanted in this contract? Is the Mayor who has NOT voted for many union contracts the past few years dragging down the process? Is the personal infighting among these members dragging down the process?

4 thoughts on “UTL and School Committee must sit down face to face..is it time to look at Fees?

  1. Did I read the paper correctly this morning?. The UTL is asking for 12% over 3 years when no one else is getting anything , at least this year. That is beyond belief and just plain greedy. I also saw the picture in the paper – again, unbelievable. Anyone involved in that one should be fired! We have some great teachers in Lowell, but fair is fair . Other city employees work hard too and deserve adequate compensation. If they can’t have a raise, then the teacher’s should not get one either. Share the pain people, you are not THAT special.

  2. So, we are not Cambridge or Concord.  We are Lowell and having fees for extracurricular activities seems like a bad idea for us.  Many families in Lowell couldn’t afford “fees” if they were applied.  They children would be deprived.  We need our children graduating from High School better prepared to do well in the world.  Shutting down extracurricular activities would detract from that.

    If you want the crass view, bad schools mean lower property values, and that impacts me—and I have no children in the Lowell School System.

    If you want the Dorothy Day answer, enriching the academic experiences of our students means more graduate, more go to college, more get good jobs, fewer go to jail, or just fall through the crack, and that is good for all of us.

    Regards — Cliff

  3. Cliff,

    Thank you for your comment. ! could not agree more about the importance of extracurricular activities. I do this both as a home owner and as a teacher. I currently teach high school in Tewksbury and I see how extracurricular activities have a power to pull students in or to give them that extra boost needed to graduate and yes sometimes to go on to college. Programs like drama, football, music, track, etc. enable students to make connections with adults on a more personal level than in the math, science or English class. Frequently such an adult provides the only good role model.

    In Tewksbury there is no more late bus, causes problems for many of our freshmen and sophomores and we have activity fees. These fees can be waived, I believe for students on free or reduced lunches, but it still prevents many students from finding their niche. Some families are reticent to apply for free lunch, others don’t make the cut, yet other financial obligations prevent them from paying the costs.

    I believe that Lowell High School is a great school. One way to maintain this is to refrain from charging student use fees.

    Si vales, valeo!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s